Skip to main content

Right-Wing Populism Emerges in South Western Ontario

Right-Wing Populism Emerges in South Western Ontario

One of the interesting features of 2021 election was the emergent strength of the People’s Party of Canada (PPC) in a number of South Western Ontario ridings. Nationally the People’s Party accounted for 5.09% of the popular votes, however, in the London and Windsor region PPC support ranged from a low of 5.2% in London West to a high of 14.6% in Chatham Kent Leamington. In the urban ridings of London North Centre and London West the results were slightly above but in line with the national results at 5.2% and 5.4% respectively. However, in other ridings the percentages went up, in London Fanshawe the party achieved 9.4% in Elgin Middlesex London the result was 11.9%, around 10% in Windsor Tecumseh and Essex, and 8.6% in Windsor West.

London West as a close-run riding is significant because the Liberal win with 36.4% was less than the 37.4% combined total of the Conservatives (32.2%) and PPC (5.2%). In other words, without the PPC candidate, the Conservatives would very well have been victorious. A similar observation can be made in the close race in Windsor-Tecumseh where the combined total of the CPC candidate (25.7%) and the PPC (10.5%) at 37.2% outstripped the popular support for the first place Liberal at 31.6% and the second place NDP candidate at 30.7%. Again, without the PPC in this race the Conservative could have won.

While the PPC as spoiler of Conservative fortunes holds only in these two ridings, the increased strength of PPC returns should attract attention as it illustrates the strength of the far-right in the region. For the most part this increase in voter support did not affect the outcomes for Conservatives in the region’s rural ridings: Karen Vecchio in Elgin Middlesex London and Chris Lewis in Essex maintained similar levels of support to their 2019 results. However, in Chatham Kent Leamington where PPC candidate Liz Vallee received 14.6% support, incumbent Conservative Dave Epp’s support decreased by 6% from his 2019 results.

The question of why this strength of the far-right emerged this election most likely mirrors the rise of voter interest in the PPC nationally, although when levels are compared to the national average there seems to have been special resonance in the London and Windsor area. Much of this has to do with the pandemic as the PPC was the only party to campaign on the rejection of masking vaccine mandates, vaccine passports, and further lockdowns. However, while new supporters may have initially been attracted by the anti-COVID measures messaging the underlying stances on reproductive choice, anti-gun control, and anti-immigration can’t be ignored. The PPC is not a centrist party. The efforts of Erin O’Toole to move the CPC more to the centre and his statements supporting a women’s right to choose and about-face on gun control would have left the rightwing fringes of the conservatism in Canada looking for a new home. The PPC provided a site to express disdain for centrist Canadian values of multicultural peace, order, and good government, but also to show commitment to a more American vision of freedom, explicitly individual freedom, envisioned as an inalienable individual right. This looks an awful lot alike the messages of Trumpist, MAGAites, and it certainly an indication that we are not immune from the from the far-right populism being propagated through Fox News.

It may very well be that the PPC emergence in this election is a one-off event tied primarily to the pandemic and anti-masking protests. However, with London still coming to terms with the hate crime that took the lives of a local Muslim family, the confirmation of far-right sentiment and support at these levels is not particularly comforting. That this support averaged nearly doubled the national popular support is even less of a comfort.

 


Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Is Low Voter Turnout Actually A Good Thing?

 [It's a provocative position. I hope my answer is a bit more nuanced. Thinking with a pen, so the views are my own and likely to change as I think about it a bit more.] The big talking point regarding yesterday's municipal election in London is the free fall debacle in voter turnout. Only 25.5% of eligible voters cast a ballot, a significant plunge from the 40% turnout in 2018 (the BRT election) and from the 2014 high of 43% (the get rid of Fontana and the Fontana 8 election).  This low turnout is seen as the reason for the rather surprising outcomes in some of the words, namely the defeat of three "incumbents."* Incumbents are considered safe bets because they have name recognition and represent the status quo for voters. Generally, the mass of voters in municipal election have little to guide their votes other than name recognition and a desire not to change things up. However, when that "mass" of voters decides not to show up, that generalized support fo...
Post a Comment
Read more

Women Mayors in Ontario

 Recently, I've been up-dating the information on women councillors in Ontario. The following table lists the women elected Mayors in the municipal elections held in October 2022. The list is organized in order of descending population of the municipality. It notes whether the Mayor is an incumbent or newly elected, while new position indicates that the Mayor is new to the position, but was an already incumbent member of council.  Of the 417 Ontario Councils which held elections, 101 are now led by women. (There maybe a few I've missed, as I have not included Reeves.) Mayor Incumbent or New Municipality Pop Acclaimed Bonnie Crombie incumbent Mississauga 717,961 Andrea Horwath new Hamilton 569,353 Marianne Meed Ward incumbent Burlington 186,948 Elizabeth Roy new position ...
Post a Comment
Read more

Women on Councils: Majorities and Lockouts

 In this blog myself and my fantastic research assistant, Leila Russell Brown (soon to be an MA student at Western University) break down the Association of Municipalities Ontario (AMO) numbers from the October 2022 Municipal Elections (check out  Ontario Municipal Elections (amo.on.ca) ). Overall, according to the AMO, more women put themselves forward as candidates in 2022, 1,939 or 31% of all candidates. This is compared to 1,808 or 27% in 2018. In total, 6,325 women and men ran in 2022. Women won or were acclaimed in 32.3% of the races, an increase from 29.4% in 2018 (AMO, 2022). This puts women on local councils at just above the 30% marker set by the UN as indicative of a critical mass , the point at which government becomes more responsive to women's needs and women are able to influence key decisions. As the AMO reports, the women who ran were slightly more successful than men in the 2022 elections. The success rate of women was 47.2% compared to 43.8% of men. In 2018,...
Post a Comment
Read more