Skip to main content

Damned If She Does

Between the election and doing revisions to the Canadian Women's Politics book, I'm rocking the blog this month. This is a departure from my election commentary and is a synopsis of the Atlantic Monthly article I tweeted out earlier this week which I am using as the basis for a call-out box in the chapter on women's representative politics. BTW: Thanks Mum for bringing the article to my attention!

Damned If She Does 

In April 2018, Atlantic Magazine ran an article clearly illustrating the problems of being an effective and ambitious woman with considerable political power. Democratic congressional minority leader Nancy Pelosi, the article argues, is “the most effective congressional leader of modern times” However, the Democratic Party’s most effect member is now considered the party’s biggest liability.

The problem is she is the most vilified politician in the United States. This vilification started in 2003, when a “twisted” version of her face was used in a Republican advertising against a Democratic congressional candidate in Louisiana. Since this, negative reference to Pelosi have dominated Republican advertising compared to her male colleagues and even President Obama. For example, in the 2016 Georgia special congressional election, Jon Ossoff, a strong Democratic contender was characterized in Republican ads as Pelosi puppet and with the statement, “Say No to Pelosi’s Man.”

That she is vilified more than her male colleague or even a male President comes down to her gender. “[P]elosi has made her ambition visible. She has gained the power to tell her male colleagues what to do. She has put herself… in control.” Such ambition is not in keeping with commonly held views as to how women are meant to behave. It’s alright for a man, but down-right transgressive for a woman. Therefore, “the more successful Pelosi is – the more she outmaneuvers and dominates her male adversaries – the more threatening she become.” Thus, it is Pelosi’s political success which is ultimately her failure, just because she happens to be a woman.

Source: Peter Beinart. 2018. The Nancy Pelosi Problem. Atlantic Magazine. April 2018. https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2018/04/the-nancy-pelosi-problem/554048/?utm_source=eb.

See also:

Jennifer Lawless. 2012. Becoming a Candidate: political ambition and the desire to run for office. N.Y.: Cambridge University Press.

Victoria Brescoll & Tyler G. Okimoto. 2010. The Price of Power Seeking and Backlash Against Female Politicians. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin. Vol. 36, No. 7, July 2010 pp. 923-936.

<End box>


Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Women Mayors in Ontario

 Recently, I've been up-dating the information on women councillors in Ontario. The following table lists the women elected Mayors in the municipal elections held in October 2022. The list is organized in order of descending population of the municipality. It notes whether the Mayor is an incumbent or newly elected, while new position indicates that the Mayor is new to the position, but was an already incumbent member of council.  Of the 417 Ontario Councils which held elections, 101 are now led by women. (There maybe a few I've missed, as I have not included Reeves.) Mayor Incumbent or New Municipality Pop Acclaimed Bonnie Crombie incumbent Mississauga 717,961 Andrea Horwath new Hamilton 569,353 Marianne Meed Ward incumbent Burlington 186,948 Elizabeth Roy new position ...
Post a Comment
Read more

The State of Gender Parity in 2019

On December 16, the World Economic Forum (WEF) released its Global Gender Index for 2020 based on 2019 country performance. Canada has dropped 3 places in the ranking since the last report a year ago.  Since 2006 the WEF has produced annual reports on the progress made toward gender equality using benchmarks based on four thematic dimensions: economic participation and opportunity, educational attainment, health and survival, and political empowerment. In the latest edition of Women, Politics and Public Policy: The political struggles of Canadian women, (Newman, White and Findlay, 2020, p. 389) we had this to say of the 2017 report:  According to the 2017 report, no country has fully closed its gender gap; four of the five Nordic countries, Rwanda (4th), and Nicaragua (6th) have closed more than 80 per cent of their gaps. And Canada? Canada does not crack the top ten; it ranks 16th out of 144 countries, which is 2 points lower than its first ranking in 2006. This d...
Post a Comment
Read more

Is Low Voter Turnout Actually A Good Thing?

 [It's a provocative position. I hope my answer is a bit more nuanced. Thinking with a pen, so the views are my own and likely to change as I think about it a bit more.] The big talking point regarding yesterday's municipal election in London is the free fall debacle in voter turnout. Only 25.5% of eligible voters cast a ballot, a significant plunge from the 40% turnout in 2018 (the BRT election) and from the 2014 high of 43% (the get rid of Fontana and the Fontana 8 election).  This low turnout is seen as the reason for the rather surprising outcomes in some of the words, namely the defeat of three "incumbents."* Incumbents are considered safe bets because they have name recognition and represent the status quo for voters. Generally, the mass of voters in municipal election have little to guide their votes other than name recognition and a desire not to change things up. However, when that "mass" of voters decides not to show up, that generalized support fo...
Post a Comment
Read more